Your browser is not supported. please upgrade to the latest version of Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, Apple Safari or Microsoft Edge.

Why Goldman Sachs’s Push for Diversity Is Unlikely to Drive Real Change

Katie Mehnert

02/20/2020

 

Goldman Sachs received a flurry of media attention after announcing at Davos that it will carry out IPOs only for companies that have at least one woman or non-white board member. As CEO David Solomon put it, “Starting on July 1st in the U.S. and Europe, we’re not going to take a company public unless there’s at least one diverse board candidate, with a focus on women.”

Among corporations that are already publicly held, women’s representation on boards is low, though not non-existent. Every company in the S&P 500 has a woman on its board of directors, and women hold about one-in-five seats on Russell 3000 company boards.

Among privately held companies, the picture is starker. An analysis of “some of the most heavily funded private companies” found that 60% do not have any women on the board, and only 7% of seats are held by women.

It’s unclear how many of those private companies may look to go public. But a recent high-profile IPO effort shows that when a company with an all-male board tries to go public, an uproar can ensue. When WeWork filed its registration for an IPO last year, the company noted its “culture of inclusivity” — but also listed its board members, all of whom were men. Controversy erupted, and the company added a woman. (This problem was soon overshadowed by numerous other problems plaguing WeWork.)

Goldman’s new rule may stem from the best of intentions. But as founder of a company that works to bring gender equality to one of the most male-dominated industries — the energy sector — I see it as misguided, and potentially damaging.

Metrics throughout the pipeline

Businesses cannot simply insert a woman into a board of directors and claim to stand for gender equality and diversity. Doing so is a fig leaf. If a company is genuinely committed to gender equality and diversity, that commitment will show up in its metrics at all levels.

I’ve seen this in action among oil and gas companies. Amid increasing pressure in recent years, many have been appointing more women to their boards. The share of women board directors in oil and gas has doubled over the past 10 years, reaching 14%. But the number of women employed in the industry has just barely budged, and is currently at about 22% worldwide (one estimate put it at 19% in 2010).

To get a sense of how committed any company is to diversity and gender equality, groups like Goldman Sachs should look at the entire talent pipeline. What is a company doing to recruit talent? What are the gender and racial breakdowns of staff in entry-level jobs, and those getting promotions each year?

Ask about the workplace culture

It’s also essential to look at culture, which is often the biggest driver of diversity and inclusion. Culture underpins diveristy and inclusion. In taking a company public, corporations like Goldman would do well to look at what employees say about the company culture. In anonymous surveys, do they report experiences with sexism, racism, and other forms of intolerance? What’s being done about these things?

We have found that asking broader questions can sometimes be the most insightful in determining whether employees feel that they opportunities based on merit. When we surveyed employees in the energy sector, we asked whether they feel a sense of belonging at their company; whether advancement is based on fair and transparent criteria; and whether the company has a “culture of genius” in which leaders assume talent is innate rather than something developed through learning.

Read More

    Company Culture
    Gender Equity/Diversity
    Pay Gap/Parity Issues
    Racial Equity/Diversity

Load older comments...

Loading comments...

Add comment

21

October 2020

Disneyland and Other California Theme Parks Get Rules for Reopening

18

March 2020

Coronavirus will be catalyst for 'monumental changes' in U.S. workforce

21

October 2020

The F.D.A. Wanted to Ban Some Hair Straighteners. It Never Happened.

06

May 2020

Sick-leave policies have changed for employers, but experts say they're tricky to navigate...

03

June 2019

Yes, you can call me disabled

You've Been Timed Out

Please login to continue